July 16, 2008

SI's alternative to the Director's Cup - Minnesota 5th in Big Ten

SI published their top 25 overall collegiate programs today. This is really a simplified version of the Director's Cup. I find these kind of rankings interesting. For obvious reasons football and basketball get all of the attention. If you live in the midwest you'll find more fans of hockey and even wrestling. And if you live in the south baseball is higher profile. But all of the minor sports get lost when evaluating the strength of collegiate athletic programs.

Here is a comparison of Big Ten teams in the rankings...

Director's Cup
Sports Illustrated
3 Michigan
6 Penn St
9 Penn St
12 Michigan
11 Ohio St
23 Wisconsin
18 Wisconsin
29 Mich St
28 Minnesota
36 Minnesota
29 Mich St
47 Ohio St
34 Illinois
48 Purdue
35 Purdue
50 Indiana
39 Indiana
NR Illinois
40 Nortwhestern
NR Northwestern
50 Iowa
NR Iowa

Basically if you are Penn State or Michigan State you understand that SI figured out how to accurately judge overall programs. If you are Ohio State or Michigan then you understand that SI doesn't know anything about sports and they should just stick to swimsuits. And if you are Iowa you still suck.

Really I like the simplicity of the SI rankings but it needs just a bit more. In a nutshell they awarded points in 22 sports (11 mens, 11 womens) for national championships (10 points), conference championships (5 pts) and top 30 finishes (2 pts). What this is missing it doesn't reward teams for very good seasons that don't end in winning a title. For instance Illinois goes to the Rose Bowl yet earns a total of two points for their season for being ranked. Purdue goes 15-4 in Big Ten basketball and has next to nothing to show for it. Taking it to the national level Memphis doesn't get extra points for being the #2 team in the country? Texas is a 2 seed, goes to Elite Eight and gets 2 points for their entire season (same as Michigan State?!).

Interesting system, it makes for good discussion and validates my arguments with friends or other bloggers that Minnesota is a vastly superior program to Nebraska, Iowa or Kentucky. But it needs to be expanded just a little bit. A sliding scale for final rank or for finishing top 3 in your conference would reward successful seasons without giving points away to terrible teams. Minnesota should not receive any points for football or a mediocre basketball season. But in my examples above Illinois should get a bump for a great football season and Purdue deserves more than two points for their basketball season.

Your thoughts?

July 11, 2008

Gopher Football Recruiting Wish List - v2

This is nothing official of course other than my 'official' wish list for 2009 recruits. I'll try to make the table actually fit so you can read the full comments.

I have moved a few guys around and added a couple names.

Significant move up - Craig Drummond (4-star DE) has moved up two spots into the #3 hole. The move was made because I feel we have a greater need along the DLine and also I'm not as sold that we have a realistic shot at Wingo or Davenport.

Significant move down - Ronnie Wingo Jr (4-star RB/Ath). Wingo seems to have cooled on Minnesota and RB isn't as much of a concern with the commitment of Lipscomb.

Added - Xavier Su'a Filo (4-star, OL), Nolan Washington (3-star CB), Eric Stephens (4-star RB), Cameron Gordon (4-star, WR) and Taylor Lewan (3-star OL).

Dropped off the List - Dan Orseske (P) - committed to Gophers, Nat Berhe (S) - not as significant of a need and although I'd love to land a good athlete with a 2.9 GPA he just isn't in my top 20 for now.

Gopher Nation Wish List



Pos Size Stars Hometown OFFERS NOTES
1 Michael Carter CB 5-11 154 4 Pompano Beach, FL FL, Clem, Georgia, Miami, Aub and others cousin to Tyrone Carter
2 Ra'Shede Hageman TE 6-6 252 3 Mpls (Washburn) FL, OSU, Neb, Wis, Ill, Iowa, Mich St a must have for Brewster
3 Craig Drummond DE 6-5 260 4 Chicago LSU, FL, OSU, USC, Tenn Top 5 DE - We have our work cut out for us here
4 Chris Davenport DT 6-4 318 5 Mansfield, LA FL, LSU, USC, Tenn, Tex, Mich, Bama, everybody I'm not holding my breath
5 Bryce McNeal WR 6-2 170 4 Mpls (Breck) committed to Michigan We win, Mich loses things might change here
6 Ronnie Wingo Jr Ath 6-3 210 4 St. Louis, MO Bama, Mizz, Tenn, OK, Neb, Kan, Ill, Iowa, Ark planning to visit, would be a great get, maybe RB
7 TyQuan Hammock ILB 6-1 220 3 Fort Wayne, IN L'ville, Mich St., Ind, MAC schools 13 sacks, 164 tackles as JR, brother to ast coach Thomas Hammock
8 David Gilbert DE 6-4 215 4 Oakland Park, FL Wis, L'ville, Pur, Scar, UCF, Mich St, etc. As of 4/30 had 3 offers, now has 12+
9 Chris Williams CB 5-11 185 4 Cincinnati, OH WV, Ind, Cincy (has academic hurdles) "The thing that shocked me was I didn't follow Minnesota football and they told me they went 1-11. I was like 'wow.' I mean if a I believe a school can really turn things around, and they want me to help I, would be interested in that."
10 Cam Gordon WR 6-2 210 4 Inkster, MI MSU, Cincy, BG not ready to make a decision, #30 WR according to Rivals
11 Eric Stephens RB 5-8 175 4 Mansfield, TX Duke, Hou, Vandy, Boise St strong, great attitude, wants to pair with Lipscomb to be the next Barber-Maroney combo
12 Nosa Equae DE 6-4 235 3 Mansfield, TX KU, Col, Iowa, Pur, L'ville Kan and Col are top 2, is planning to visit
13 Xavier Su'a Filo OT 6-4 285 4 Provo, UT USC, Aub, LSU, Mia, ND, BYU, Col, Stan Moses Alipate is trying to convince him MN is the place to be, don't hold your breath
14 Rodney Smith WR 6-6 202 4 Miami, FL Aub, FSU, OleMiss, Mizz, Tenn, many others 3.0 GPA, but kind of a longshot imo
15 Nolan Washington CB 5-11 165 3 Burien, WA Idaho fast with 34" vert. Loves Oregon but they have not yet offered. One I'd particularly like to see end up at MN
16 Dwayne Difton WR 5-11 166 4 Ft. Lauderdale, FL BC, Pur, Sflor, S Miss, Syracuse seems high on Auburn if offered
17 Taylor Lewhan OT 6-6 270 3 Scottsdale, AZ ASU, UT St likes ASU, dad went to Minn
18 Matt Garin DE 6-4 220 3 Apple Valley, MN AZ St, Ore St, Stan, Wash St, AirForce, MACs plenty of Pac 10 schools but no other BCS schools, interesting
19 Anthony Jones OLB 6-2 200 3 Chandler, AZ AZ, ASU, OreSt, Wash St
20 Artice Kellam S 5-11 180 NR Miami, FL OleMiss, SoCar

July 9, 2008

Golden Gopher Football Rivals - Part 1

RIVAL
a:
one of two or more striving to reach or obtain something that only one can possess
b: one striving for competitive advantage

I want to take a look at the three teams Gopher fans view as our rivalry games. Bear in mind that I am defining these teams as rivals, not peers.

For decades the Gophers have competed in the Big Ten and sought to add 5 trophies to the trophy case each season.

1-Big Ten Championship Trophy
2-Rose Bowl Trophy
----------
3-Paul Bunyan's Axe
3-Floyd of Rosedale
3-The Little Brown Jug

Since very few of you reading this (if any) can remember a B10 or Rose Bowl trophy making it's home in the Bierman Building, the next best thing has been our attempts to bring home one of our three traveling trophies. It is rivalry trophies such as these that are part of what makes college football great and keeps Gopher fans interested in throughout terrible seasons. We will get into much greater detail but these rivalries and the stories behind their trophies are fascinating.

It is a little known fact (thank you Cliff Claven) that the Gophers actually won the first game in all three of these trophy games (Michigan was actually a 6-6 tie, but since it ended their 28 game winning streak and we were heavy underdogs it is considered a victory).

There is often much debate as to which is the "biggest" of the rivalries.

Some say Michigan is the biggest and most important to win. This isn't a natural rival and to say we have been "rivals" is laughable for Michigan fans. But the point here is that if we want to be the best we have to beat the best. Beating Michigan is more of a statement and puts us in a better place to accomplish other goals than beating Wisconsin or Iowa will typically do for us. But there certainly is no bitterness or dislike for each other. Michigan fans want to beat Ohio State and Michigan State. Gopher fans have more passion for beating Iowa and Wisconsin. But the Little Brown Jug has been around for a long time and might be my favorite of the traveling trophies.

The further you live south of the Twin Cities, the more you will find Iowa to be our biggest rivals. I grew up in south central Minnesota and cared much more about brining home Floyd of Rosedale than I cared about the Axe or the Jug. Geographically this makes sense. This has also been our most successful rival as it is the only one of the three where we have a winning record. The story behind Floyd of Rosedale is interesting and amusing that an actual pig was sent from Iowa to the Governor's office to pay the debt.

My best guess would say that the majority of Gopher fans would say Wisconsin is our biggest rival. With the Twin Cities being so close to the border you usually have at least a couple Badger fans in your office, at church and/or living on your block. The close proximity of these Badger fans is also amplified on Sunday's when they turn into Packer fans so the rivalry carries over. From our calm and level headed perspective Badger fans seem to be more obnoxious than our other rivals. But then again that may just be that they are here in greater numbers and they are Packer fans.

Before I get too in depth with each rival, I encourage you to take let your voice be heard and vote as to which rivalry you think is biggest.

July 3, 2008

a WAY early look at 2008-09 Basketball

Tomorrow is the 4th of July (for those of you who didn't already know this) and starting next week the countdown to football should really heat up. But before we all go into full on gridiron mode I'd like to take a moment to look ahead to basketball.

This week I made a trip over to St. Paul to watch some of our current and incoming Gophers play in the Howard Pulley Pro City League. I am not going to reproduce any game recaps done by Ryan James over at Rivals but I'm going to use my observations there to help form my thoughts on the 2008-09 season.

Starting Lineup (best guess)

PG - Al Nolen

I am a big fan of Nolen and what he brings to the court. Watching him play at Pro City League (PCL) reminded me how good he is defensively but is also reiterated that he is not much of a shooter. He reminds me of Eric Harris early in his career. Harris worked his tail off to become a better shooter and by his senior year shot nearly 39% from behind the arc. But I'm not concerned with Nolen's shooting (we have scorers), I love his defense and what he does to get the rest of his team involved. The PCL is great for a guy like Nolen who gets to guard guys like Troy Bell, Kammron Taylor and Ariel McDonald. For next season I am counting on a similar defensive presence and improved passing on the offensive end. He was able to penetrate the lane last year but often threw passes away or couldn't quite thread the needle in traffic.

SG - Devoe Joseph

I'm taking a shot here, but I think Joseph will be our starting SG by the time we get to the Big Ten season. I'm probably wrong as this spot could go to Westbrook, Hoffarber or even Bostick but I'm taking a shot here. Joseph as most of you know was allowed to try out for the Canadian national team. He did not make the team but is considered to be an integral part of Canadian basketball future. But again the competition and increased speed/intensity can only be a good thing for a kid like Joseph. Jason Thom has this to say about Joseph on his Inside Training Camp blog...

The kid is a shooter...more importantly, he is coachable. Mike Malone, Dave Smart and Leo all took him aside at different times to explain something in practice. He listens, asks questions and without the blank stare that many young players have. It was a glimpse into Canada’s future when he was grouped with Sammy D and Carl English during a few drills.
HERE is a link to a short video of Joseph talking about the privilege of playing with Canada on your jersey while he shoots around.

Basically Joseph is a big time wild card. He could potentially come in and stand out early as a scorer or he could blend in with the handful of other perimeter players we have as he matures and fills out that thin frame.

SF - Devron Bostick

JUCO national player of the year and a big time scorer. After watching Bostick at PCL I'm really not sold on his jump shot. I watched him closely during warmups and was not impresed, but then questioned my original analysis when he drained a deep three early in the contest. But Bostick then went 2 for his next 9. This was just one game but to me he didn't have a great follow through and I don't see a consistent shot coming from him when the Big Ten season speeds things up a little bit. I could be completely wrong as Bostick shot 6/12 from NBA threes in his previous PCL game. And he did attempt 186 threes last year making 33% of them. But my hunch is that he will not be reliable or shoot that % next year in the Big Ten.

With that said the kid is a scorer. I envision him starting here in the small forward spot and getting plenty of minutes at SG throughout the game when Tubby goes bigger. At 6'5" he isn't ideally suited for SF but smaller lineups and three guard offenses are more the norm in college ball these days and I envision a small starting lineup.

Bostick will be our leading scorer.

PF - Damien Johnson

Again, smaller starting lineup will require Johnson to play PF which he often played last year when Coleman was on the bench. Johnson also played on Tuesday in PCL and he continues to amaze me in how far he has come since his freshman season. 15 pts, 16 rebounds, a couple blocked shots and an impressive put back dunk. I'm counting on Johnson to really be the heart and soul of this team. I don't know if he is ready or even capable of leading but if he lets his play do the talking others will follow. DJ will not be our leading scorer but will probably lead the team in rebounding.

C - Ralph Sampson

Big Jon Williams is the more experienced returner in the post but I think Sampson will earn the starting spot. This is the guy I was most looking forward to watching at PCL but he was not present. It is hard to gauge Sampson's impact on next season but everything I have read says that he is continually improving and will be ready for the Big Ten. I think his preferred position is PF, but until we have a center we can count on I expect he'll start at C. Envisioning a lineup where we have someone else at C and Sampson at PF is fun to think about but for now neither Iverson or Williams can be relied on to start at C.

His first PCL game has him scoring 20 and grabbing 6 boards. This was against a weaker team but encouraging none the less for a kid just out of high school.

BENCH (in order of who will enter the game first)

G-Lawrence Westbrook - will come in at either guard spot. Westbrook had an inconsistent season last year, but at times was our primary scorer. The kid isn't afraid to put the ball up, but he also was prone to some awful turnovers. An increase role in the offense and better decision making will allow Westbrook to be more successful this year but also with the incoming talent I see the offense being geared more for the likes of Sampson, Joseph, Bostick and Hoffarber. Westbrook should be used to adjusting by now. He'll be a key perimeter defender and an occasional offensive shot in the arm.

SG-Blake Hoffarber - needs to get better at everything except shooting. I don't think The Hoff is as stoic as others do, but he does need to do more than just shoot. The kid is arguably the best shooter in the conference and that will be his primary role. I don't care that he can't create his own shot or that he won't penetrate the lane. Not his role on the offense. What he does need to get better at is defending the perimeter and he needs to contribute as a rebounder. I do believe he is athletic and is capable of more than just shooting but at the same time his shooting is what other teams will fear and it is exactly what we need him to provide.

C-Jon Williams - Big Jon will likely see the biggest increase in minutes. I don't think you'll see much more scoring out of the big man but he is going to have to be a factor defensively and most importantly on the boards. As his minutes creep up to about 25 min / game can he average 5 of 6 reb/game? That will be significant.

C/F-Colt Iverson - I was able to see Iverson play this week at PCL. When he did not have the ball he looked like a plodding big white guy. But with the ball or attacking the glass Iverson displayed some athleticism and desire. The kid has 7 boards in each of his first two PCL games. Much like Williams I don't see Iverson as a scorer we will be counting on this year. Minimum shots and any points we can get will be a bonus but rebounds and defense will make a big difference for this team. I'm expecting 15-20 min per game.

F-Paul Carter - Our second JUCO commit but not yet on campus. Carter is another wild card who could really be a significant contributor or not. Carter and Johnson are probably our only true SF type players and will give us some size/length when playing at the SF spot. My hope is Carter is able to defend athletic SF's around the conference (think Raymar Morgan). He put up solid numbers last year as a first year JUCO. In an interview with his JUCO coach Carter's length and athleticism kept coming up as his strengths so hopefully he'll be a big boost in all areas off the bench.

G-Jamal Abu-Shamala - I have never been a supporter of JAS on this blog. I just don't think he is a Big Ten caliber player. This summer JAS has tried out for and made the Jordanian National basketball team. They did not qualify for the Olympics but JAS will get the opportunity to compete with and against a different level of competition which can only benefit him in preparation for his senior season in Minnesota. But he is essentially a less athletic and not as good a shooter as Hoffarber. Expect about 10 min per game.

G-Kevin Payton - again someone I do not endorse as a viable option off the bench. From my perspective Payton is taking up a scholarship I'd rather use on a PG for next season. There are rumors that his junior season will actually be his last as the staff is pushing for him to graduate this year and then possibly help out coaching (much like Ryan Saunders). I endorse this move. I am sure Payton is a great guy but he just offers very little value on the floor and that is what we are talking about here.

G-Travis Busch - another scholarship that belongs with someone more talented. Busch's scholarship is already in play to be yanked next year, but considering he is a walk on he has to know this was potentially coming. I love his hustle, when given minutes last year he outworked more talented players but that hustle is best utilized in practice to make others better. Glad he's on the team, don't want to see him in games.


Some random predictions...

Leading Scorer - Devron Bostick
Leading Rebounder - Damien Johnson
Steals Leader - Al Nolen
Assist Leader - Al Nolen
Blocked Shots - Ralph Sampson
All three-point categories - Blake Hoffarber

Final record? - can't give that without a schedule
Big Ten Finish - 3rd place behind Purdue and Ohio State. 3rd place will be a battle with Wisconsin and Michigan State
NCAA Tournament - YES


I am eagerly watching for the Gophers to release their non-conference schedule. Thus far all we know is that they'll be playing Louisville in the Stadium Shootout (Dec 20) and Virginia in the Big Ten/ACC Challenge (Dec 2).

July 1, 2008

Blake Hoffarber up for his second ESPY

The ESPY Nominations were released today.

Blake Hoffarber's shot to beat Indiana in the Big Ten Tournament has earned a nomination. I don't know the stats or ESPY records but he would have to be one of the few (if not only) amateurs to win more than one ESPY. Really he could become the only person to win multiple ESPY's who's name is NOT Tiger Woods.

Click HERE to start voting.

Hoffarber's competition?

#1 - Super Bowl: Eli Manning to David Tyree...


This one is obviously the heavy favorite. It is arguably the best play in Super Bowl history. I'm not sure the legend that is Blake Hoffarber is enough to beat Mr. Manning. (You've all seen the real play a million times and I like Tecmo Bowl so go to YouTube to find the real play if you want to see it.)

#3 - Mississippi Miracle...


This DIII game where Trinity needed 15 laterals to score a TD and win the game. Cool play, but probably #3 in the final standings here.


#4 - Nash Shoots and Scores...


I was expecting a Steve Nash shot, but teah, that was Rick Nash, not Steve (hockey, not basketball). Cool play but this will not win.


The Manning/Tyree catch is clearly the favorite to win this but Hoffarber has a chance to pull off the upset. Let's get Gopher Nation out there and voting to get Blake his second ESPY.


And here is the brilliant highlight of the year for Gopher basketball...

June 30, 2008

Welcome to Gopher Nation Kid - Dan Orseske

The verbals are coming in at a torrid pace lately.

As media outlets prognosticate on the upcoming Big Ten season there are two things Gopher fans can count on this year. 1-The Gophers will be picked 11th nearly 100% of the time. 2-The only Golden Gopher you will see on any pre-season all conference lists is punter Justin Kucek. Kucek is a senior so brining in punter to replace him is obviously important for Brewster and Co.

The coaching staff has received a verbal from their top punter priority. Dan Orseske has decided he will make the move from Chicago to Minneapolis next fall to compete for the starting punter position as a true freshman (P-Blake Haudan will be a senior next fall so he may get a year as the starter).

Size: 6-3, 195 lbs
High School: Brother Rice (Chicago, IL)
Stars: none at this point
Rank: NR
Notes: Brother Rice water polo has won 13 state championships (Orseske does not play WP)
Other Offers: Northwestern (take that LTP)

It is hard to gauge how good a high school punter truly is but after performing well at a Gopher camp this summer, Orseske earned a scholarship offer. He took a week to think it over and this weekend Orseske gave the Gophers his verbal. This verbal brings our commit list to eight as we get to the midway point of the summer.

At the Kohl's Punting and Kicking camp in May, Orseske averaged 44.9 yds per punt with an average hangtime of 4.08 seconds. Those numbers were nearly 5 yds further with .30 seconds of extra hangtime than the next best punter at the camp.

Orseske has spent his summer making the tour of football camps (Illinois, Northwestern, Cincinnati, Pittsburgh, N. Illinois). His only other offer was from Northwestern, but ultimately the decision was down to Minnesota or Illinois (who he expected to offer).

Hopefully this team gets to a point where a punter isn't as much of a factor as Justin Kucek has been. An offense the moves the ball and a defense that gets some three-and-outs does more for field position than an All-American punter, but having a strong and accurate leg can do a lot to bail you out.

Dan Orseske, we welcome you to Gopher Nation with open arms. No offense to you but the less we see of, you the better.

----------

On a related topic, lets talk about recruiting pipelines for the Gophers. In a season and a half of recruiting for Brewster and staff there are a couple of areas where the Gophers are making significant inroads. With the addition of Orseske, it adds another kid from the Chicago area. I don't know that a punter becoming the 3rd commit from one area makes us a recruiting heavyweight in the area, but if Brandon Green, Johnny Johnson and now Orseske can have some success we should be able to demonstrate that Minnesota is a viable destination for Chicago area recruits.

The two biggest recruiting hot beds in the country are Texas and Florida. Brewster isn't exactly batting 1.00 in Florida with the flame out of Harold Howell, the de-comittment of Padric Scott and the transfer of Tray Herndon. We continue to pursue highly rated athletes from the Sunshine state but have yet to land a big fish or two to make us viable players down there. Maybe WR-Victor Keise will be the first in a long line of Florida studs to give the Gophers some of that southern speed.

Texas, however, has been a different story. Landing the Skyline-4 has clearly established the Gophers at that particular school, and hopefully the Dallas area. But our Texas pipeline has tapped into more than just the Dallas area. Eric Lair (3-star TE) was an early commitment last summer and this springs verbal from Hasan Lipscomb (4-star RB) gives us another major athlete from the Houston area. Six highly ranked players from the two largest cities in Texas gives us a fighting chance with future recruits. The key to all of this is of course sustaining some success on the field. If the Gophers are able to demonstrate some Big Ten competitiveness in the near future then kids from Texas (or Florida, California, Ohio, wherever) will be more apt to braving Minnesota winters for a chance at starring as a Golden Gopher.

----------

CB-Michael Carter - Florida recruit would give us street cred and much needed help in the secondary
DE - Craig Drummond - Chicago native who needs to get on that I94 tollway north and give us our second 4-star Chicagoan.

June 28, 2008

Welcome to Gopher Nation Kid - Brooks Michel

The 2008 Recruiting class was heavy with wide receivers and defensive players at all positions. So far the 2009 class has loaded with offensive linemen. Typically offensive linemen take a redshirt year so the timing is probably about right since we currently have a young line. These incoming commits will take 2009 to redshirt and most of them will likely watch in 2010 then have 3 years to earn starting spots.

Brooks Michel, welcome to Gopher Nation.

Size: 6'7", 280 lbs
High School: Carmel HS, Indiana
Stars: 3 (Rivals)
Rank: NR
Notes: defending state champs, All-State Honorable Mention
Other Offers: NC State, Kentucky

For those of you looking forward to the 4 or 5 star, top 100 kid, you may be disappointed. For the second commit in a row this isn't that rock star verbal, but maybe you can take comfort in the adage that offensive line is the hardest to project and accurately assign stars. The godfather of recruiting rankings, Tom Lemmings, has been quoted as saying so, and after reading Bruce Feldman's "Meat Market: Inside the Smash-Mouth World of College Football Recruiting" it also became clear that stars mean nothing to coaching staffs. Gopher fans also know this very well as Greg Esslinger (2-star) and Mark Setterstrom (3-star) were lowly ranked and unheralded players who ended up dominating the Big Ten.

Back to Michel. He is a big kid who as a junior helped lead his Carmel Greyhounds to the Indiana State Championship. He is our third offensive linemen of the seven verbals we have received to date.

Let's hope he brings that championship pedigree to the Gophers.

June 27, 2008

Kevin McHale has this NBA Draft thing all figured out, doesn't like OJ Mayo

I know this is not a Timberwolves' blog and in my own defense I have been 100% on topic throughout the life of Gopher Nation. But I feel compelled to throw in my two cents on the Timberwolve's draft and Kevin McHale pulling another draft day trade. Since McHale is a Gopher alumn I think I'm still batting 1.00

I also know that I'm treading on very thin ice here as I try to criticize not just one of the best athletes in the history of Gopher athletics, but I'm also going to question the greatest GM in all of sports (Forbes said it, not me).

The principals of this trade are only half of what bothers me, I'll get to that in a minute. But I get this vibe from McHale that he thinks he knows something nobody else knows. He thinks the joke is on everybody else but in truth they are all laughing at him. What I mean by this vibe is that his track record for drafting is terrible no awful no abysmal, I can't find a word to describe it. Yet he continues to operate each subsequent draft like the previous. With such an unbearable draft record (KG being the lone exception and one could argue he got lucky) why would you just not take the sure thing and be happy with it.

Sitting at #3, McHale did the right thing by drafting Mayo. Mayo has certain skills that directly translate to the NBA and he will contribute immediately (more detail below). But that wasn't good enough for KMc so he traded him. While the entire basketball world agrees that Mayo can shoot the NBA three, has the ability to be a very good defender and has a chance to be a perennial All-star, McHale decided he knew something they didn't and traded Mayo to Memphis.

What did he get in return? He got Mike Miller who will be a nice addition as a productive player and Kevin Love. Love might be fine and also a productive player, but his upside is not what Mayo's is. The NBA is a league of stars and explosiveness. Kevin Love is neither (neither is Miller for that matter).

In an effort to be more specific lets take a look at each players listed strengths/weaknesses (courtesy of stolen from Draft Express)...

OJ Mayo
Strengths Weaknesses
Size Between a PG / SG
Versatility Poor shot selection
Scoring Instincts Turnovers
Shot-creating ability w/either hand Does not get to the FT line enough
NBA 3-pnt range Reliance on outside shot
Ability to pull up sharply off the dribble Struggles to get by defenders
Basketball IQ Year older than class
Court Vision Low shooting percentages
Confidence/Swagger
Perimeter Defense
Work Ethic
Coachable

For my money you can throw a couple of those weaknesses out the door.
  • Tweener? - at 6'5" and NBA range he will play SG and provide some min at PG if needed.
  • Year Older than his class? - So he'll have only a 12 year career not 13.
  • Turnovers/Shot selection/reliance on outside shot? - if he truly is coachable and has a good work ethic (listed in strengths) those can all be corrected.
  • Character Flaws - I honestly believe this has been overblown. I know Mayo's attitude and confidence (arrogance) does not play well in Minnesota, but to be great at this level you have to have swagger. You have to not only want to take big shots you have to believe nobody can guard you and that you are the best person on the floor to take that shot. His other flaws are meaningless once he signs a contract. He hasn't been arrested and most importantly he is known as coachable and having a good work ethic. Those last two attributes have been glossed over because of the scandal surrounding his agent friend while still an amateur player.
His strengths are exactly what you are looking for in an NBA perimeter player. Draft Express says best case scenario is Mayo has a career similar to Chauncey Billups. That is pretty much spot on.

Kevin Love
Strengths Weaknesses
Productive Size
Hands Explosiveness
Strength Plays below the rim
Fundamentals Lateral quickness
Intensity Defensive potential
Ability to score in the paint Not much Upside
Excellent Touch
Range out TO 3-pnt line
Free Throw shooting
Basketball IQ
Passing Skills
Winning attitude
Little downside

When your strengths include attributes like fundamental, productive, excellent touch and passing skills; you are not destined for NBA greatness. And what kills me from within is that his weaknesses include NBA requirements like size, explosiveness, lateral quickness and playing below the rim? Best case scenario for Mr. Love? Personally I see best case being a Christian Laettner type career. Solid player who puts up some decent numbers but will never be more than a #3 option on a good team. Not capable of leading into the playoffs or carrying a team when needed.

Apart from their individual skill sets, Mayo would fit much better on this team than Love. I know we are full of perimeter players but a backcourt of Foye and Mayo to pair with Jefferson in the post is a very good trio. I see two offensive sets that are actually dangerous and require gameplanning by the opposition starting immediately.

1-Mayo coming off an Al Jefferson pick n roll is dangerous. Mayo needs just a little space provided by the screen to hit a mid range pull up (a strength of his) or to dish to Jefferson.

2-Foye and Jefferson have an inside out 2-man game on one side while Mayo stretches the defense on the backside waiting to who his NBA ready 3-point jumpshot.

Love on the Wolves roster? He is a good sized PF who is not big enough to play C (remind of you anyone on the Wolves roster?). Regardless of how good Love may or may not be we don't need another PF. Best case we have two good PFs starting side by side. Again I go to what is a proven formula for success in today's NBA. Two big men doesn't do it. You have to spread the floor with some explosiveness and shooting from the outside to go with someone who can dominate the paint. Tim Duncan doesn't need another big man clogging things up, he needs Parker and Ginobili to keep the defense spread and knock down open shots. Jefferson as a post up PF is great, but where does Love play into this? Setting a back side screen to free up Miller? Finding an opening on the backside baseline for a 10 ft jumper? I think that kind of player can be found without giving up the #3 pick in the draft.

In all fairness the rest of the pieces of this trade I like a LOT. Mike Miller fits in great here and should be productive immediately. Jaric and Walker had to go and it frees up considerable cash in the very near future. If you want to buy into 2 > 1 philosophy then this was the right move. But in a league of stars you brought in two role players for someone who might ("might" is of course the operative word here) be a star.

----------
TWolves Blog agrees with me. I think it is kind of hard to tell what "Let's just say my throat is still burning from the vomit." really means.

PagingJimShikenjanski doesn't comment on the trade but isn't happy about the NBA.

TNABACG loves the lateness of the trade making for incorrect headlines in your paper edition of the Star Tribune (what is the paper edition thing?)

John Hollinger of the WWL disagrees with me (DAMN). "When we break it down, it's hard to see how Minnesota loses: Love is, in my estimation, the better of the two prospects."

Chris Mannix (from SI) agrees with me as well. "With Mayo and Al Jefferson as cornerstones, the Wolves were going somewhere. Now, Minnesota will have to build around a talented but undersized frontcourt (Love, Al Jefferson) without a marquee guard."

Timberwolves' owner Glen Taylor also agrees with me - "Our people thought that Mayo had far more upside than Love," Wolves owner Glen Taylor said. Quote can no longer be found on STrib but TWolves Blog still has it for us to ponder.

----------

NOTE: I like the pick of Petrovik (I'm not bothering to look up spelling).
OTHER NOTE: picture of a GIDDY Kevin McHale was stolen from Star Tribune, picture of players wearing hats, from ESPN

June 26, 2008

New Poll on right sidebar...

I want to know how this breaks down in Gopher Nation...

Where do you stand on the current football coaching staff.

1 - Tim Brewster is the guy and will lead us to a championship level. If you land in this group you believe in the Ron Zook blueprint. Recruit, Recruit, Recruit, then the wins will come. It may take a few years and along the way the first couple seasons may be absolutely brutal but once the talent level is raised and those kids get some experience they will start winning games. As many may recall it wasn't very long ago that Zook was labeled as a great recruiter but a terrible game coach. Those labels are gone for now and soon the Brewster naysayers will have little to say as well.



2 - I miss Glen Mason. At least Mason never gave us a 1-11 season. While we knew a shot at the Rose Bowl was going to take some luck and even those shots would be few and far between. But Coach Mason was right, things were really bad before he got here, he brought us to a new level and under Brewster you are head right back to the bottom 2 or 3 of the conference on an annual basis. We had established one of the best running games in the country and fielded a team that was bearable to watch.



3 - I'm still on the fence. I think it was time for Mason to go but I'm not yet sold on Brewster. But if he can keep recruiting like this I'm willing to take a couple seasons like 2007 with the shot at greatness. I am not willing to call this hire a failure, but so far I'm not impressed.

I encourage you to vote with some passion, in the end I just want to know what % of Gopher fans are actually going to be patient, who misses Mr. Mason and who has bought the snake oil.

June 25, 2008

Mark Schlabach has no foresight

Schlabach put out his 2008 Bowl predictions and I'm appalled that the didn't include your Minnesota Golden Gophers. I didn't expect he'd put us in the Rose Bowl until next year but nothing? (ed note: sometimes sarcasm is hard to pick up so don't crucify me in the comments)

Here are the Big Ten teams and their slotted bowl opponents...

BCS National Championship: Georgia over vs. Ohio State
Rose Bowl: USC vs. Wisconsin
Capital One: Florida vs. Illinois
Outback: Penn State vs. Tennessee
Insight: Nebraska vs. Purdue
Alamo: Kansas vs. Michigan State
Champs Sports: Florida State vs. Michigan
Motor City: Ball State vs. Iowa

Seriously, Iowa? That leaves Indiana, Northwestern and Minnesota the only Big Ten teams not practicing for two extra months. In all seriousness with our non-conference schedule and getting Iowa, Northwestern and Iowa at home we could make a run at that Motor City tilt with Ball State. I know that is a Glen Mason-esque goal, but baby steps to Pasadena. Beating Michigan at home just might get us to San Antonio for the Alamo Bowl.